On Friday the kids wanted to make flubber again. My little gal, who had been home with fever on and off most of the previous two weeks, looked a bit limp still, and I could not possibly say no to her request. And then of course, my two fours, who always love flubber, and who, if I had remembered clearly, had the most spectacular time only a couple of Fridays ago with flubber, when our eight taught us the miraculous trick of blowing flubber bubbles, and I fell in love with flubber again myself then, too, taking pictures and laughing out loud along with the kids, well, of course those boys wanted to do flubber again, too. So, we did, but I went reluctantly to the gallows, having done flubber so many times with so many kids in my life that I could not imagine having fun this time.
For me, flubber is a science trick we learned a long time ago when we participated in a training at the Boston Children’s Museum for family child care providers. There was money then, and they paid for a bunch of us providers from all around the Boston area to come to the Museum at night, paid for fabulous trainers, the museum staff and others, paid for lovely meals, for museum memberships for each of our children’s families, and for buses, my god, buses, to transport our little children to the Museum three times over the course of our training. From that experience, I believe the longest surviving remnant in our program, besides the strong memory of flusher times, is flubber. One of the museum staff made it with us one night when we were there alone, without kids all the providers did the hands on stuff, and Liana and I loved the flubber, loved the simplicity of ingredients, white glue, water, borax, color for kicks, took the recipe back to day care and some years later, I think, it took off with kids. One year we made it millions of times, then it went nearly dormant awhile, then came back last year full force.
We have done flubber so many times the last two years I put the recipe on the wall in the project room. In Sharpie on a piece of tag, I have written, and drawn pictures to show younger kids what to do, Put 2 T. (tablespoons) glue in a bowl. Add 2 T. water. Stir. (Here there is a spoon in a bowl). Add color. (Here there is a small dropper bottle shown tipped upside down with a drop going into the bowl). Add 2 t. (teaspoons) borax solution. Stir.
We have done the recipe so many times it is hard for me to imagine what could be surprising today. I drag my feet, gather supplies from the kitchen, measuring cups, bowls, and from the project shelves, measuring spoons, plastic spoons for stirring, and from the supply cupboard, gallon of glue. I set up for the kids, pouring glue into smaller measuring cups, giving each child a plastic bowl and spoon, starting the project by showing them how to measure the glue by dipping the tablespoon measure into the cup of glue and dumping it drippingly into the plastic bowl, doing the same with the water. Then the kids mix, wonder what next, one exclaims, “Color! We need color!!” and of course we do, but in our case, we seem to need streams, not drops of color, making our flubber so deep blue and red the kids exclaim and give the colors deep names like night.
The kids stir and stir and stir, still no flubber. “More color!” they exclaim with glee, and they add so much it is like midnight in their bowls. And their excitement is contagious, I go from bored to flubberized, their enthusiasm my borax solution. But to them we are making flubber all the time, even without that magic ingredient.
And here the kids start to wonder. “When is it going to be playable?” says one, or some such thing. I actually got out pen and paper and scribbled down the kids’ words for a long time during this part of the play, but my words are so messy I am not sure I could recreate them any better here if I got the paper than if I just do my best from memory. (I also got out my camera and took a million pictures, even dropped it again, and it may be broken, even after the snapping back together trick I tried yesterday, the zoom was jerky and seemed not within my control, but the snapping made it better, I think.) “We need more glue!” and they add more glue. “We need more color!” “Yeah, more color!” and they add more color. “More water!” and they add more water. They stir and stir and stir and stir and at this point, I am astounded. I remember just now as I am retelling that the first moment of astonishment actually came much earlier, when I put the gallon of glue down on the table next to my four, he said to me, “Why are you putting that glue there?” !!!! This one threw me for such a loop (I think it was so unbelievable I must have actually blocked it out!) I had to walk to the kitchen to get the bowls with my eyes so wide, calling to Liana “They want to know WHY WE NEED THE GLUE THERE!!??” You would think I would know by now that children need millions and millions of repetitions to learn hard things, but still I was astounded that my four, who loves flubber, who has been with us for what Liana reminds me is going on four years, has not fully registered that to make flubber you start with glue. But of course, kids still don’t really register after years of making applesauce how the apples go from hard to sauce, they will still say things like, “they melted” or “we mushed them with the musher (the food mill)”, they seldom believe me when I say it was the cooking that made the apples into sauce. But then I remember reading Howard Gardner and his studying of how we all learn science, and his reminder that most of us live with these misconceptions, don’t really ever learn or understand how the basic science around us works, and as I write this, I think, I don’t either, while I know the apples are cooked, and remember something about cell walls breaking down or chemical changes, I would be hard pressed to give a truly scientific explanation of how apples transform to sauce, mostly magical thinking even here in the mind of this teacher who for many falls of life, nearly all those I can remember, has made applesauce from scratch. So, no real surprise on the glue, but it put me in a playful mood to see how much more there was to learn.
Which is why I held off on the borax solution, until our fours persisted, “What else do we need?” “What more do we need?!” and at last my eight, steadily pounding at different pieces of wood, I later learned, splitting them down the middle in frustration, not intent, called out, “Borax! You need Borax solution!” to which the fours began to chant, “borax, borax, we need borax, borax, borax, we need borax!” And from there it was all an experiment, no more recipe, no more teacher lead activity, they added borax straight from the bottle, no measuring spoons, and saw what would come, discussed the ways one might vary the experiment (more glue, more water, more color, more borax solution), drew conclusions (more borax makes it stiffer, more borax makes it too hard to blow bubbles with flubber), made judgments (more borax is not necessarily better), and tested hypotheses (trying to blow bubbles with many different versions of flubber, to see if the more borax flubber did or did not work for bubbles, how well, how poorly).
And then, just when I thought it could not stray further from my limited imagination of flubber as boredom, something new happened again, our homeschooling family arrived, and for the first time, these French kids and their mom discovered flubber, and they had a blast, too, covered the drop cloth with glue and water and borax and flubber, made tie dye flubber, stretched it out in a film between their hands, exclaimed over it’s potential for next Halloween, compared it to the french slime of the mother’s childhood and the dimestore slime of mine, made hot pink and lavender purple flubber, and cleaned, and cleaned and cleaned the table cloth, working hard as only good self-sufficient learning to farm and keep bees and raise chickens and build coops and someday build a house from scratch homeschoolers can do.
So, that is my story of flubber, of how a teacher/caregiver who has been working with kids her whole adult life can be surprised and have her energy revived in just one moment with children. Kids do that if you let them, if the day is open to surprise we can all keeping serving and saving our way through life, a concept I thought about a lot this winter, after reading about it in my Ode, Magazine for Intelligent Optimists, the idea that through good work a person can both serve others and save oneself, to turn the ideal on it’s head like that was helpful to me, to stop trying so hard to save others, but to work instead to serve others, and in the process, to hope to be saved myself, has worked much better, and it has turned out to be more fun:)